“You two just need to communicate better.”
As trauma survivors in relationships, we’ve all heard this advice countless times. Well-meaning friends, family members, couples therapists, and relationship resources promise that better communication skills will fix our problems.
We diligently try. We practice “I” statements. We work on active listening. We study conflict resolution and try to stay calm during disagreements. Yet despite our best efforts, we still find ourselves exploding in anger, shutting down completely, or walking away from conversations feeling more misunderstood than when we started.
We then question ourselves: What’s wrong with me? Why can’t I communicate like everyone else? Why do these techniques work for others but not for me?
Here’s what’s rarely acknowledged: generic communication advice isn’t designed for trauma survivors.
Traditional relationship advice builds on assumptions about how the nervous system works—assumptions that don’t apply when you have a trauma history. When your nervous system carries trauma responses, using standard communication techniques is like trying to perform surgery while riding a roller coaster—the foundation simply isn’t stable enough to support the skill.
The “Just Communicate Better” Trap
Traditional couples therapy operates on one fundamental assumption: that both people can access their rational, thinking brains during conflict and choose different responses.
This assumption works perfectly well for people without trauma histories. However, it completely falls apart when trauma is involved.
When you have a trauma background, certain triggers can instantly activate your nervous system. These might be specific words, tones of voice, or even facial expressions.
In that state, the part of your brain responsible for language, reasoning, and emotional regulation essentially goes offline. You literally cannot access the communication skills you learned because that part of your brain becomes temporarily unavailable.
Dr. Dan Siegel calls this “flipping your lid” – when the prefrontal cortex (your thinking brain) loses its ability to regulate the amygdala (your alarm system). During these moments, you’re not operating from your adult self who knows how to use “I” statements. Instead, your traumatized nervous system takes control, convinced you’re in mortal danger.
Why Your Best Intentions Disappear During Conflict
When Sarah When Sarah and Mike came to see me after their previous therapy experience, Sarah explained their situation perfectly: Mike came to see me after their previous therapy experience, Sarah explained it perfectly:
“Our therapist kept teaching us ‘I’ statements and active listening techniques, which was helpful. But when Mike would shut down during our sessions as I talked about my feelings, I couldn’t remember any of those tools. My body would burn with anger and my brain would go blank with panic, or I’d become so angry I couldn’t think straight.”
What Sarah was experiencing wasn’t a failure of willpower or memory—it was her nervous system switching into a protective response. In her case, she would become angry, triggering her trauma response of “fight.”
When Mike withdrew, her brain didn’t interpret this as “Mike is feeling triggered and overwhelmed.” Instead, it registered “dangerous person who doesn’t see or care about me, I am unlovable”—because that’s what being ignored or neglected meant in her childhood home.
For Mike, his trauma response was to go into “freeze” mode, his protective mechanism when overwhelmed with feelings of failure and shame.
When we’re triggered by something that reminds us of past trauma, our amygdala essentially hijacks the prefrontal cortex. The thinking, rational brain goes offline, and we operate from fight, flight, or freeze responses. In this triggered state, your nervous system has limited options: fight (get defensive and attack), flight (leave the conversation or change the subject), or freeze (shut down and stop talking entirely).
No amount of communication training can override a nervous system in survival mode.
When Therapy Makes Things Worse
Many traditional approaches actually increase emotional activation during sessions. Therapists are trained to “lean into” conflict, encouraging couples to express their feelings more directly or dig deeper into their hurt.
For trauma survivors, however, this approach can be retraumatizing. Instead of creating safety and connection, it can trigger emotional flooding—that overwhelming experience where your nervous system becomes so activated that you literally can’t process what’s happening.
I’ve seen couples leave traditional therapy sessions more dysregulated than when they arrived, then struggle for days to reconnect. The therapy was inadvertently triggering their trauma responses instead of healing them.
Moreover, when therapists don’t understand trauma, they often misinterpret protective behaviors. What looks like “resistance” or “avoidance” is actually the nervous system trying to prevent retraumatization. When these behaviors are challenged rather than understood, couples feel more broken and hopeless than before.
The Missing Foundation
Here’s what most therapists don’t understand: trauma survivors need to learn to regulate their nervous systems before they can effectively communicate. It’s not a character flaw or a lack of commitment—it’s basic neurobiology.
When your nervous system is dysregulated:
- Your window of tolerance shrinks dramatically
- You perceive threats that aren’t actually there
- Your body prepares for danger, not connection
- Your capacity for empathy and perspective-taking disappears
- You literally cannot access the parts of your brain needed for healthy communication
Traditional therapy tries to teach advanced relationship skills to people whose nervous systems are still stuck in survival mode. It’s like trying to teach calculus to someone who’s having a panic attack.
The “Window of Tolerance” Problem
Trauma survivors typically have a much narrower “window of tolerance”—the zone where you can handle stress and still function well.
When you’re inside this window, communication techniques can work beautifully. But the moment you step outside of it (which happens easily during relationship conflicts), those same techniques become impossible to access.
Imagine your window of tolerance as a narrow hallway. When you’re walking calmly down the middle, you have room to maneuver, think clearly, and choose your responses. But trauma survivors are often running down this hallway. They get knocked into the walls by triggers they didn’t see coming. While you’re bouncing off those walls (dysregulated), you can’t perform the careful, precise movements that good communication requires.
Generic advice tells you to walk gracefully down the hallway. But it doesn’t acknowledge that yours might be narrower than others’. It’s filled with unexpected obstacles. You might need to learn how to widen it before you can master the graceful walking part.
When Communication Techniques Backfire
For trauma survivors, traditional communication advice can actually make things worse. Here’s why:
“Use ‘I’ Statements”
Becomes Self-Blame
When you’re triggered, “I feel hurt when you…” can quickly become “I’m too sensitive” or “I’m overreacting again.” The technique designed to help you express your needs instead reinforces the shame you already carry about your trauma responses
“Stay Present and Don’t Leave”
Ignores Safety Needs
Many trauma survivors need space to regulate when activated. Advice to “stay and work it out” can feel like being trapped. This escalates the nervous system response rather than calming it.
“Express Your Feelings” – Assumes Access to Feelings
When your nervous system is hijacked, you often can’t identify what you’re feeling, let alone express it clearly. You just know something feels terrible, dangerous, or wrong.
“Listen Actively” Requires a Calm Nervous System
Active listening demands that you temporarily set aside your own emotional reaction to focus on your partner’s perspective. When you’re triggered, your nervous system is screaming about your own safety. It literally cannot spare the resources for empathy or perspective-taking.
The Missing Piece: Nervous System Regulation
Here’s what traditional communication advice misses entirely: trauma survivors need to learn nervous system regulation before they can effectively communicate. It’s not a nice-to-have skill—it’s a prerequisite.
You can’t think your way out of a dysregulated nervous system. You can’t communicate your way out of a trauma response. You have to address the body’s alarm system first, then engage the thinking brain second.
This isn’t a character flaw or a sign of weakness. It’s basic neurobiology.
Your nervous system developed these protective responses for good reasons. They kept you safe during genuinely dangerous situations. The problem is that they’re still active during safe conversations with people you love.
What This Means for Your Relationship
Understanding why communication advice fails doesn’t mean giving up on better communication. Instead, it means getting the foundation right first. Rather than starting with advanced relationship skills, you need to start with nervous system basics:
- Learning to recognize when you’re approaching the edge of your window of tolerance
- Developing tools to stay regulated during mild stress
- Creating safety signals with your partner for when you need to pause and regulate
- Gradually expanding your capacity to handle relationship stress without becoming dysregulated
Once you have these foundational skills, traditional communication techniques can actually work beautifully. But trying to use them without this foundation is like building a house on unstable ground. No matter how good your construction techniques are, the building won’t hold.
What Actually Works Instead
So if traditional communication advice doesn’t work for trauma survivors, what does? The answer lies in approaches that work with your nervous system instead of against it. These techniques help you stay regulated so you can actually access your communication skills when you need them.
In Part 2 of this series , I’ll show you exactly what trauma-informed communication looks like, including specific scripts and techniques that work even when your nervous system is activated. You’ll discover why regulation-first communication creates better outcomes than trying to push through triggered states, and how to have difficult conversations without leaving your window of tolerance.
Your Next Step Toward Healing
If you’re reading this and thinking, “This is exactly what we need,” trust that instinct. Your relationship doesn’t have to be another casualty of unhealed trauma.
I offer free consultation calls where we can discuss your specific situation and determine if trauma-informed couples therapy is right for you. During this call, we’ll explore:
- Your trauma history and how it’s showing up in your relationship
- Why previous therapy attempts may not have worked
- What trauma-informed couples therapy would look like for your specific situation
- Whether my Whole-Healing System approach is a good fit for your needs
You don’t have to keep repeating the same painful cycles. You don’t have to choose between healing your trauma and saving your relationship. With the right trauma-informed approach , you can do both.
Ready to explore a different way forward? [Book your free consultation here] and let’s discuss how trauma-informed couples therapy can help you create the secure, healing relationship you both deserve.
Eva Fernandez, LMFT, specializes in trauma-informed individual and couples therapy using her proprietary Whole-Healing System. She helps trauma survivors create secure, lasting relationships through nervous system regulation, attachment healing, and trauma-informed communication skills.
0 Comments
Trackbacks/Pingbacks